Tuesday, February 21, 2006

Bente: Irving thought it "fun to provoke"

A report in the Guardian suggests that in fact Irving has not really changed his denier spots. Interestingly, Irving's partner, Bente Hogh is also reported as saying that Irving went to Austria, despite the ban, because he "thought it was fun to provoke". Here are some excerpts:
Irving jailed for denying Holocaust

Three years for British historian who described Auschwitz as a fairytale
Ian Traynor in Vienna

Tuesday February 21, 2006

[...]

State prosecutor Michael Klackl said: "He's not a historian, he's a falsifier of history." Arguments over freedom of speech were entirely misplaced, he added: "This is about abuse of freedom of speech."

Last night Irving's partner Bente Hogh said he had brought his imprisonment on himself by going to Austria despite the ban. She said: "He was not jailed just for his views but because he's banned from Austria and still went. David doesn't take advice from anyone. He thought it was a bit of fun, to provoke a little bit."

Irving pleaded guilty but under Austrian law the trial went ahead. Judge Peter Liebtreu called Irving "a racist, an anti-Semite, and a liar", citing the verdict delivered by Justice Charles Gray at the high court in London in 2000 when the historian lost a libel case against an American writer and academic and was bankrupted.

Irving said that defeat had cost him $13m, but supporters were sending donations to help him fight yesterday's case.

The judge repeatedly asked Irving if he still subscribed to the views articulated in the 1989 speeches. "I made a mistake saying there were no gas chambers in Auschwitz," he conceded. He claimed the Holocaust figure of six million murdered Jews was "a symbolic number" and said his figures totalled 2.7 million.

He said he was not sure how many died at Auschwitz, but he mentioned a figure of 300,000, a fraction of the accepted total. And he still believed Hitler protected the Jews and tried to put off the Final Solution - the systematic killing of all European Jews - at least until after the second world war.

2 comments:

Randy M. said...

Howdy Ms. Lipstadt,



Heard you last night being interviewed on CBC Radio's "As It Happens" program.

Very good...

Read in Canada's Globe and Mail newspaper yesterday about David Irving's troubles in Austria. Very good... (Good that he's going to jail, that is.) Made me pick up my copy of Richard J. Evans book "Telling Lies About Hitler" and start reading it again.

What I don't understand is what happened to him? He used to be not such a bad amateur historian when writing about Erwin Rommel, etc., but his Holocaust denial is just ridiculous. Has he always been a neo-Nazi or when did he go off the deep end?? Evans book isn't really clear about that...

Anyway, I believe he deserves his jail time but I also believe the media shouldn't be making a circus out of it. It is probably for the best just to ignore Irving so he doesn't get free publicity so he can sell his books and other crap...

Really amazing, and sad, that in the year 2006, there is still such enormous antisemitism around the globe. Thank goodness for fighters for the truth such as yourself...



Best wishes and shalom,



Randy Meingast

Owen Sound, Ontario, Canada

http://meingast.tripod.com/family.html

Dave said...

I almost feel sorry for Bente, but apparently she's a racist, too.

Yes...I think that's it...Irving thought he could mess around with the Austrian legal and court system, and make them look stupid and foolish, as he did with the British media and historians in the 1983 Hitler diaries mess.

Well, now he's a convicted felon, which should certainly slow down his lawsuits and publishing career.